Edgar Russ Distinguished Violinmaker
Edgar Russ Distinguished Violinmaker
  • Видео 406
  • Просмотров 3 136 992

Видео

CNC vs Human : Who Crafts the Better VIOLIN ? #violin #shortsCNC vs Human : Who Crafts the Better VIOLIN ? #violin #shorts
CNC vs Human : Who Crafts the Better VIOLIN ? #violin #shorts
Просмотров 704День назад
In this video, I interview Violinmaker John Kirk, who crafts violins using a CNC machine. John shares his insights on how much of the violin-making process can be automated and where the human touch is still essential. We explore the balance between CNC precision and traditional craftsmanship. Can a CNC machine truly replace the artistry of a skilled luthier? Watch as we delve into this fascina...
New Violins vs Great Master Violins - is it POSSIBLE?!New Violins vs Great Master Violins - is it POSSIBLE?!
New Violins vs Great Master Violins - is it POSSIBLE?!
Просмотров 3,5 тыс.4 дня назад
In this video, I react to "Why Can't We Make New Stradivari Violins?" and share my thoughts on why modern violins can match the quality of Stradivari's masterpieces. Join me as I explore the factors that influence violin sound, including craftsmanship and materials. Don't forget to like, comment, and subscribe for more insights into violin making! Meanwhile all the best from Cremona Edgar Searc...
What's the Violinmaker's BIGGEST Enemy? #shortsWhat's the Violinmaker's BIGGEST Enemy? #shorts
What's the Violinmaker's BIGGEST Enemy? #shorts
Просмотров 5 тыс.8 дней назад
Constant learning and growing is probably the most important ingredient to be successful. Every time a human being is making something he/she is in a constant dialog with himself. Time pressure, the desire to finish something quick or within a specific time frame are already a threat against a perfect made thing. Let me explain: If a violinmaker who builds for his entire life one instrument aft...
Modern Shine or Timeless Look? The Violin Varnish Showdown!Modern Shine or Timeless Look? The Violin Varnish Showdown!
Modern Shine or Timeless Look? The Violin Varnish Showdown!
Просмотров 3,6 тыс.11 дней назад
In this video, I explore the debate of Modern Shine vs. Timeless Look for violin finishes. Should you choose a freshly varnished instrument or one with an antiqued finish? Join me as I examine the pros and cons of each style, sharing my techniques for achieving an authentic antiqued look inspired by the great masters. Let me know in the comments which finish you prefer! Don't forget to like, su...
Cutting OFF the VIOLIN Scroll - a CRUEL sound EXPERIMENT #shortsCutting OFF the VIOLIN Scroll - a CRUEL sound EXPERIMENT #shorts
Cutting OFF the VIOLIN Scroll - a CRUEL sound EXPERIMENT #shorts
Просмотров 1,7 тыс.15 дней назад
Too often people ask me what we actually need the scroll for. Indeed, we do not need it, but it is an integral part of the entire instrument. How does it sound without it and how big is the impact of the scroll? I demonstrate this in this exciting video. I cut away the scroll of a fully playable violin and we sound check it before and after the scroll removal. I would say this is a Hero Violin ...
Unlock the Three Pillars for Choosing a ViolinUnlock the Three Pillars for Choosing a Violin
Unlock the Three Pillars for Choosing a Violin
Просмотров 5 тыс.18 дней назад
In this video, I discuss the three key factors to consider when choosing your violin. Whether you're a beginner or an experienced player, finding the perfect balance is crucial for making a great investment in your instrument. Join me as I break down these essential pillars, offering insights and tips to help you make an informed decision. Don't miss out on this valuable information that can gu...
DIY Cremona VIOLIN Makers LUNCH #shortsDIY Cremona VIOLIN Makers LUNCH #shorts
DIY Cremona VIOLIN Makers LUNCH #shorts
Просмотров 1,9 тыс.22 дня назад
I love violinmaking! But if you are hungry you can not work properly since you can't focus on what really matters. So here a short video of what I like to cook in a one hour lunch break. Today I invite you ate my house a few minutes out of Cremona and I cook for you and the the rest of my workshop a delicious plate of Pasta with home made tomato sauce. Hope you enjoy it and looking forward to t...
CNC vs Human : Who Crafts the Better VIOLIN ?CNC vs Human : Who Crafts the Better VIOLIN ?
CNC vs Human : Who Crafts the Better VIOLIN ?
Просмотров 8 тыс.25 дней назад
In this video, I interview Violinmaker John Kirk, who crafts violins using a CNC machine. John shares his insights on how much of the violin-making process can be automated and where the human touch is still essential. We explore the balance between CNC precision and traditional craftsmanship. Can a CNC machine truly replace the artistry of a skilled luthier? Watch as we delve into this fascina...
I've NEVER seen Someone so HAPPY #shortsI've NEVER seen Someone so HAPPY #shorts
I've NEVER seen Someone so HAPPY #shorts
Просмотров 3,6 тыс.29 дней назад
If you're interested in learning violinmaking like Reagan, consider joining my Online Violinmaking Academy to discover every aspect of this craft firsthand: edgar-online-violinmaking-academy.com/p/complete-violinmaking-course Thank you, Reagan, for participating in this video and for visiting my workshop. Most importantly, thank you for trusting my Online Violinmaking Academy to help you achiev...
What's the Violinmaker's BIGGEST Enemy?What's the Violinmaker's BIGGEST Enemy?
What's the Violinmaker's BIGGEST Enemy?
Просмотров 2,1 тыс.Месяц назад
Constant learning and growing is probably the most important ingredient to be successful. Every time a human being is making something he/she is in a constant dialog with himself. Time pressure, the desire to finish something quick or within a specific time frame are already a threat against a perfect made thing. Let me explain: If a violinmaker who builds for his entire life one instrument aft...
The Weather FORECAST of your VIOLIN sound #violin #cello #violinist #music #classicalmusic #shortsThe Weather FORECAST of your VIOLIN sound #violin #cello #violinist #music #classicalmusic #shorts
The Weather FORECAST of your VIOLIN sound #violin #cello #violinist #music #classicalmusic #shorts
Просмотров 1,9 тыс.Месяц назад
Hey everyone! 🎻 In my latest video, I dive into how climate factors like temperature and humidity can seriously affect the sound of a violin. From cracks to shifting neck angles, extreme conditions can spell trouble for your instrument. Join me as I explore this important topic in violin care! 🌡️💧 Meanwhile all the best from Cremona Edgar Searching for the right Violin🎻, Viola🎻, Cello🎻 or Doubl...
Cutting OFF the VIOLIN Scroll - a CRUEL sound EXPERIMENTCutting OFF the VIOLIN Scroll - a CRUEL sound EXPERIMENT
Cutting OFF the VIOLIN Scroll - a CRUEL sound EXPERIMENT
Просмотров 6 тыс.Месяц назад
Too often people ask me what we actually need the scroll for. Indeed, we do not need it, but it is an integral part of the entire instrument. How does it sound without it and how big is the impact of the scroll? I demonstrate this in this exciting video. I cut away the scroll of a fully playable violin and we sound check it before and after the scroll removal. I would say this is a Hero Violin ...
EVERY piece of a VIOLIN needs to be TUNED? #violin #cello #violinist #classicalmusic #music #shortsEVERY piece of a VIOLIN needs to be TUNED? #violin #cello #violinist #classicalmusic #music #shorts
EVERY piece of a VIOLIN needs to be TUNED? #violin #cello #violinist #classicalmusic #music #shorts
Просмотров 2,5 тыс.Месяц назад
Tuning VS Measurements VS Sensations emotions impressions …... Violinmaking is a very interesting trade. Every detail has its impact on the final result. There are no short cuts during the making process. Therefore there are many systems to achieve better results and all have its pro. The most contra point is actually that makers rely too much on one system and while they focus on one new metho...
Cremona VIOLIN Makers LUNCHCremona VIOLIN Makers LUNCH
Cremona VIOLIN Makers LUNCH
Просмотров 1,1 тыс.Месяц назад
I love violinmaking! But if you are hungry you can not work properly since you can't focus on what really matters. So here a short video of what I like to cook in a one hour lunch break. Today I invite you ate my house a few minutes out of Cremona and I cook for you and the the rest of my workshop a delicious plate of Pasta with home made tomato sauce. Hope you enjoy it and looking forward to t...
Why Violin "F" HOLES are in This Shape?! #shorts #violin #violinist #classicalmusic #orchestraWhy Violin "F" HOLES are in This Shape?! #shorts #violin #violinist #classicalmusic #orchestra
Why Violin "F" HOLES are in This Shape?! #shorts #violin #violinist #classicalmusic #orchestra
Просмотров 1,2 тыс.Месяц назад
Hi everyone!!! Today we'll be analyzing an interesting topic: the f-holes of the violin. These f-holes have evolved along with the instrument throughout its history. If you want to learn how to draw and cut perfect f-holes for your violin, I recommend signing up for my ViolinMakingAcademy, where you can learn EVERYTHING about violin making edgar-online-violinmaking-academy.com Meanwhile all the...

Комментарии

  • @scottakam
    @scottakam 21 час назад

    Is there any group of people that love myths more than musicians?

  • @sebastianbucur5135
    @sebastianbucur5135 День назад

    why couldn't you get a local youtuber with a professional camera an filming skills to do this?.. We want to see close-ups, details..

  • @sebastianbucur5135
    @sebastianbucur5135 День назад

    that first violin sounded INSANE!!!

  • @christopherw4527
    @christopherw4527 День назад

    John shop is in Billings. Small town? Hardly.

  • @lorenzosm1644
    @lorenzosm1644 День назад

    Hello. Why don't your videos allow automatic translation? I follow you but I don't understand you.

  • @KFRogers263
    @KFRogers263 День назад

    Cello student here. How much does this apply to a student grade cello? I'm in the process of looking for my next cello but in the mean time, it would be nice to squeeze our some better response from my C string. Thanks

  • @ssb73q
    @ssb73q День назад

    Hi, Strad are an historical investment, nothing more.

  • @lightspiritus
    @lightspiritus 2 дня назад

    Hi, maestro! I am very interested of such kind of videos, where you telling us about the history of the great violin makers. Thank you

  • @feliperojito
    @feliperojito 2 дня назад

    DURISIMO el tipo

  • @user-jk2lk2et9n
    @user-jk2lk2et9n 3 дня назад

    Hi I would like you to make a video about the body length(LOB). If I'm missing the video, somebody please let me know. Thanks😊

  • @gregmonks
    @gregmonks 3 дня назад

    A trivia question: what was the make of the violin played by the violinist opposite Paul Tortelier on the 1st Thomas Beecham recording of Don Quixote? Quiet fiddle but the most silky tone I've ever heard.

    • @markuswx1322
      @markuswx1322 3 дня назад

      I don’t have that answer, but here you are, implying that there is something very special in the tone of a particular violin-when all those double blind tests showed that neither players nor listeners could distinguish one fiddle from another. Give the performer some credit, at least.

    • @gregmonks
      @gregmonks 3 дня назад

      @@markuswx1322 You really need to avail yourself of a course, or a least of book explaining, the mechanics of logic. No one said anything about not being able to tell one fiddle from another. Many violins have distinct voices, sometimes to the extreme. The QUALITY of violin sound is the thing that can't be ascribed to any particular make or model. The ASSUMPTION that led to the creation of the double-blind tests, starting in the 19th century, was that anyone with a good ear would READILY pick a Cremonese fiddle from the lot whose sound was on display. The tests invariably DEMONSTRATED that the best ears in the business rated the Cremonese fiddles lower, in terms of perceived quality, than new-made offerings by living luthiers. Just a suggestion- get yourself one of these. It'll save others a lot of grief over the course of your life. www.abebooks.com/9780070037182/elements-logic-Barker-Stephen-Francis-0070037183/plp

    • @gregmonks
      @gregmonks 2 дня назад

      @@markuswx1322 That's not what I said. Not even close. What the double-blind tests were created for was to see if the best ears in the business could detect a particular make of violin. The assumption was that they could easily pick out the fiddles made by the old masters. In practice that's not what happened. Not only that, but they were asked to judge perceived quality based on the sounds they heard. Newer instruments have been winning in that department since the 19th century. This is exactly what makes the double-blind tests so interesting: despite the evidence, the myths persist.

    • @markuswx1322
      @markuswx1322 2 дня назад

      @@gregmonks That’s all fair enough, and I did attend the 2017 tests closely. I believe it does follow in a general way that the perceived tone of a violin from the listener’s point of view will likewise reveal little about whether the tone came from the player or the instrument, the presumption leaning toward the player. For example, expert listeners in those tests were sometimes able to detect the familiarity of certain players with their [famous] violins. The PREFERENCE of what one hears, as respecting old vs. new violins in a direct comparison, was addressed in the tests. Your question about the silky tone being particular to the violin in the performance you heard, to me requires a skill that hasn’t been objectively demonstrated anywhere.

    • @markuswx1322
      @markuswx1322 2 дня назад

      @@gregmonks You’re giving yourself impossible airs over someone else’s grasp of logical inference, which borders on trollery. It’s the kind of debate that unfortunately rouses a few self-assertive intellectual coxcombs who can’t resist instructing everyone in the room. After a very few posts, no one else will be listening. Personally, I am moving on.

  • @mtv565
    @mtv565 3 дня назад

    Have heard intermediate to advance level violins made more than 20 years ago, during the 1990s. Now they really sound almost like (if not 100% like) Stradivarius violins!!! They really open up their sound gradually over the years.

  • @mtv565
    @mtv565 3 дня назад

    Luthiers pay high prices for wood aged 2-3 decades to make master violins. Even Yamaha artificially age their wood to make their master level YVN500s range violins.

  • @myeyesarewaiting
    @myeyesarewaiting 3 дня назад

    Would love to see a video where you add weight to the scroll somehow and then glue it back on, and then compare again.

  • @markosterman419
    @markosterman419 4 дня назад

    If you are going to have text … please don’t have a thumbnail picture of the violin maker obscuring it.

  • @violatione
    @violatione 4 дня назад

    The new masters have surpassed the old masters. You've probably heard a Zymuntowicz or a Greiner in concert and had no clue.

    • @markuswx1322
      @markuswx1322 2 дня назад

      I don’t know if they’ve been surpassed, but today’s finest players have used so-called tonal copies for some time. Who could argue that they’d have sounded better if only they had a Golden-era Strad? A bit insulting really. My guess is that some of those exalted soloists leave their Cremona masterpieces in the insurance company vault when they go on tour. No one is the wiser. And there are a few not-so-secret secrets about the antiques: Some have been hollowed out by regraduaters to the point where new wood had to be grafted into the top plate to prevent the bridge from sinking in. The original intention of the maker would have been lost, sometimes decades ago. The debate will go on, but it’s probably time to send the old works to the preservationists where they can be revered and only occasionally played.

  • @mtv565
    @mtv565 4 дня назад

    There are already modern violins which sound as great as (and some even sound better than) an average Strad or Guar! Not all Strad/Guar violins are of equal quality;- some are better while some are worse due to damage or poor maintenance over the decades.

  • @Ilcannone1743aficionado
    @Ilcannone1743aficionado 4 дня назад

    500 likes...great video...the best part of the violin is when you play a little and can feel the difference and listen different instruments to appreciate the voice ...(that could change any time depending on many factors)....

  • @Skinny_Karlos
    @Skinny_Karlos 4 дня назад

    I want a Guarneri del Gesu, myself. Only approx. 150 left but that's still 149 left for other people. Why, oh why can't I have one ?? And don't reply with $$ being my problem - THAT I well know !!

  • @nickiemcnichols5397
    @nickiemcnichols5397 4 дня назад

    Not better, just a lot more expensive.

  • @mylesjordan9970
    @mylesjordan9970 4 дня назад

    The “mystique of Stradivari” is actually the mystique of the artists who played them. Very practical people, they preferred the flat arching of the Strad model because they could give a concert one day at sea level, then another the next day in the mountains, without having to adjust-or even carve-another soundpost. Even today, amateur musicians are very curious what brand of rosin their favorite players use, because they believe if they use the same one they’re a step closer to their ideal sound. I have played many of the greatest Italian instruments-including the Castelbarco Stradivari (aka the Bass of Spain) in Washington D.C. and the Sleeping Beauty Montagnana in Philadelphia-and can attest, to my astonishment, that even a mass-produced, Chinese student cello can compare with them in every way if set up properly as a concert instrument. Russ, who makes much better instruments, is correct; the quality of the sound setup is everything.

    • @mtv565
      @mtv565 4 дня назад

      In blind tests, many people actually prefer the modern violins over the Strad

    • @mylesjordan9970
      @mylesjordan9970 4 дня назад

      @@mtv565 In this case, not so blind.

    • @gregmonks
      @gregmonks 4 дня назад

      My takeaway is that the next time I play, I should check the local sea level and keep an eye out for nearby mountains.

    • @mtv565
      @mtv565 4 дня назад

      @mylesjordan9970 And also natural ageing of the wood (instrument owned for many years) + many years of playing = even an intermediate level instrument can "open" up to sound very close to a Strad!

    • @mtv565
      @mtv565 4 дня назад

      @@gregmonks Strad and Guar violins cost so much because of their history and collector's value! Not so much of the sound as modern violins have proven to sound very close or even better!

  • @peterbaxter8151
    @peterbaxter8151 4 дня назад

    As you spoke, my mind strayed to the concept of value for money. A modern violin from a great maker seems to make more sense.

    • @nickiemcnichols5397
      @nickiemcnichols5397 4 дня назад

      I own a three year old fiddle, and I like it. If I ever buy another one, I think I’d like a brand new one.

  • @roylin3490
    @roylin3490 4 дня назад

    fun jai is crazy

  • @myeyesarewaiting
    @myeyesarewaiting 4 дня назад

    I once read that makers of stringed instruments would add weight to either the head or bridge of an instrument to increase the bass frequencies. This video seems to corroborate that.

  • @picksalot1
    @picksalot1 4 дня назад

    Nice critique of the other video. I think you were very objective and fair. Thanks

  • @gregmonks
    @gregmonks 4 дня назад

    The Strads were never great violins. They cost the equivalent of around $2600 US new, if I'm remembering correctly (in today's market), no Strad has ever taken top spot in a double-blind test, current, living luthiers have always taken the top spots, and the rest is hype and baloney. If they were so great, then luthiers would not have been busy in the early 19th century ripping the necks out by the roots and remanufacturing the old Strads to sound like the then modern violin. Regardless, they sound nothing like they did when they were new.

    • @knightsimperium4277
      @knightsimperium4277 4 дня назад

      Never heard more bull** and ignorant words of unknowledge.

    • @markuswx1322
      @markuswx1322 4 дня назад

      @@knightsimperium4277 Right. Edgar Russ’s estimate of ~50 years is correct. Acoustic research, the availability of information and tools has resulted in more good violins being made today than ever before. The Italian masters perfected the craft more than 300 years ago but were unable to quantify it and make it consistent as we can now. I don’t know where this guy got the $2600 number. I don’t think he does either.

    • @fatdoi003
      @fatdoi003 4 дня назад

      very bold statement but top string players will disagree with you...

    • @gregmonks
      @gregmonks 4 дня назад

      @@fatdoi003 They're probably violinists. Speaking as a violist, I take violinists with a grain of salt. Huge egos, buckets of opinions, tiny, wee brains.

    • @watching7650
      @watching7650 4 дня назад

      @@markuswx1322 The $2,600 estimate is a complicated calculation involving exchange rates and cost of living ("the Homemaker's Shopping Cart" type) from the 1700s Lombardy to today's US. This guy must be some kind of bank employee or somesuch -- that explains the post.

  • @a.s.clifton544
    @a.s.clifton544 4 дня назад

    “Just like me.” Now that takes confident nads. Bravo!

    • @peterbaxter8151
      @peterbaxter8151 4 дня назад

      To be honest, my violins and violas are all around 100 years old. I chose them based on the size of my budget at the time and sound and responsiveness compared to the others I was offered.

  • @winterhorse290
    @winterhorse290 4 дня назад

    From a Strad to a cigar box fiddle, they all have their own sound. It just depends on what you want or like.

  • @DanielMessiasSantos-gy8bk
    @DanielMessiasSantos-gy8bk 4 дня назад

    Hello, Edgar Ross! Your channel is really good! Thank you so much I realized this craft demands great reflection in all aspects one's intention; and last but not least, time and patience

  • @-ClayMan-
    @-ClayMan- 5 дней назад

    Najgorszym wrogiem profesjonalnego twórcy skrzypiec jest kornik😂

  • @aze4308
    @aze4308 6 дней назад

    nice

  • @aze4308
    @aze4308 6 дней назад

    nice

  • @dianaedwards9032
    @dianaedwards9032 7 дней назад

    Did you ever meet Gil Solaman. Probably wrong spelling but he lives in Scotlanf. What he doesn't know about violina isn't worth knowing

  • @i_cam
    @i_cam 7 дней назад

    Bruh i assumed it was gonna be the violin player lol

  • @myeyesarewaiting
    @myeyesarewaiting 7 дней назад

    Very interesting. I agree it sounded less bright. The interesting question is "why?". Carbon fibre acoustic guitars exist and it is said the carbon fibre is very neutral... That it doesn't absorb or deaden any frequencies in the way different species of wood will lessen the volume of different frequencies. If we assume that to be true then the logical explanation for the wooden bridge being bright would be that it is failing to transmit all low/mid frequencies into the body

  • @srijay7717
    @srijay7717 7 дней назад

    4:41 5:19

  • @mellissadalby1402
    @mellissadalby1402 8 дней назад

    I put an Otto low mass fine tuning tailpiece on my student violin and it really woke up the instrument. I didn't realize how much the 4 fine tuners on a wooden tailpiece dampen the violin. The Otto low mass fine tuning tailpiece (at less than 12 grams) actually weighs less than many wooden tailpieces.

  • @jimbelle3087
    @jimbelle3087 8 дней назад

    Now that's messed up, We're is the rest of the video, I'm missing out.

  • @bloke1348
    @bloke1348 8 дней назад

    Yeah that's a great philosophy. ....actually now that I think of it that could apply to all artforms

  • @robertbowlin1
    @robertbowlin1 8 дней назад

    Thanks!

  • @gregmonks
    @gregmonks 8 дней назад

    When you consider that there are limitless possibilities, why limit yourself to just two?

  • @ghlscitel6714
    @ghlscitel6714 8 дней назад

    Do you want to have a measuring tool that can give you thickness results from a ready-made violin without disassembling it into parts with an accuracy of 0.1 mm? Pls, let me know.

  • @arfanhanba6161
    @arfanhanba6161 8 дней назад

  • @MAITLANDVAUGHAN-TURNER
    @MAITLANDVAUGHAN-TURNER 8 дней назад

    HEY DUDE!!! Great videos! you need more subscribers!! (i NEVER subscribe to youtube channels, but i subscribe on yours!) your channel is a "hidden gem" from what i've played, I feel like the "antiqued" look also lets the wood vibrate a little more in a way i like. If it's very glossy or if it's a thick varnish, i don't like it as much. And of the violins i have played i notice the same trend whether it is a $$$ violin or a $$$$ violin (i've only played one $$$$$ violin, before so i can't say, but that one was nice, of course)

  • @devinwhall9407
    @devinwhall9407 8 дней назад

    As a former cnc operator and someone starting to build instruments, I feel that they can both exist. I feel that the front and back plates could easily be roughed out by cnc then the master can fine tune them by ear. I even have an idea to balance the plates similar to how jet turbines are balanced that would be fun to experiment with.

  • @amezcuaist
    @amezcuaist 8 дней назад

    So now try Titanium tailpiece ---with Real Gut strings. Salt and Pepper together .

  • @amezcuaist
    @amezcuaist 8 дней назад

    The titaniom makes the tone harsher . For the player --the Bach piece needs the phrases to be separated and have their own character rather than one long continuous piece. Accentuate parts to give them some individual feeling..Lighter going up --tiny pause --and heavier going down .Build in the force of gravity .Exagerate a bit .

  • @bubbles9816
    @bubbles9816 9 дней назад

    Ay ay ay ….

  • @TnSn5
    @TnSn5 9 дней назад

    What's the difference on the violins that have protruded backs and front shapes from regular ones